Introduction
Efficiency in operating room (OR) setting is a fundamental factor for ensuring that high-quality, cost-efficient care reaches patients receiving orthopedic shoulder surgical care. This has led to the question of the ideal course of action that should be taken to maximize efficiency in the OR in the most realistic, cost-effective manner. The introduction of a dedicated personnel responsible for optimizing efficiency of OR protocols has been cited to have benefits such as decreasing surgical and OR time, turnover time, and length of stay.1-5 The purpose of this study is to evaluate the efficiency of primary shoulder arthroplasty cases including anatomic and reverse shoulder arthroplasty, performed by a single sports medicine fellowship-trained orthopaedic surgeon at a high-volume academic center after hiring a dedicated surgical technologist to supplement the usual shoulder arthroplasty OR team.
Methods
Markers of efficiency are present in the electronic medical records of patients, so this necessitated retrospective chart review of primary shoulder arthroplasty cases including anatomic (ATSA) and reverse (RTSA) total shoulder arthroplasty by a single surgeon. Procedurally this entailed looking at cases that were collected during the 15 month period prior to hiring this technologist and compared to the 15 month period after the hire. There was a 3 month “wash-out” period between these two periods to take into account training with the exclusion criteria including 1) any arthroplasty cases outside of the 15 month range and 2) revision arthroplasty cases. The primary outcome measures analyzed include: (1) Absolute surgical time (AST) defined by the start time from skin incision to the end of dressing application; (2) Absolute turner time (ATT) defined by the time of the patient leaving the OR to the time that the OR is ready for the next patient for the subsequent case; and (3) Room ready time for the start of the first case of the day defined as the scheduled 7:30 AM start time. Secondary outcome measures of inter-operative time between cases. The statistical analysis was performed using PRISM with a one-tail T-test to compare time periods’ mean primary and secondary outcome measures.
Results
The mean AST for RTSA showed a decrease of 14 minutes after the arrival of the dedicated surgical technologist (P < 0.00015). All arthroplasty cases in the series showed a decrease of 8.9 minutes in ATT with the dedicated surgical technologist (P < 0.016). Mean room ready time showed a decrease of 5 minutes (P < 0.000007). With ATSA, there was not a statistically significant difference for AST (P = 0.247).
Conclusion
The findings provide an evidence-based framework for evaluating the advantages of including a dedicated surgical technologist as a supplement to the usual OR team. In our center, the findings suggest a dedicated surgical technologist can lead to a reduction in AST in all shoulder arthroplasty and AST in RTSA. This time-saving change can reflect better utilization of the OR resources to help institutions provide more efficient patient care.
Figures and Tables
| Metric: | Before Arrival | After Arrival | Observations | P(T<=t) One-Tail |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total Reverse Absolute Surgical Time | 114.5421687 | 100.4337349 | 83 | 0.000154835 |
Wheels Out to Room Ready (Turnover Time) |
41.875 | 32.91666667 | 24 | 0.015778416 |
| Room Ready First Case of the Day | -1.526315789 | -6.605263158 | 76 | 6.89923E-06 |
| Total Pre-Op Time | 89.44736843 | 80.86842105 | 76 | 0.003659577 |
Anatomic Total Absolute Surgical Time |
113.8292683 | 110.2926829 | 41 | 0.247269309 |