Skip to main content
Concurrent Session

Chart Your Course to E-Resource Success: A Team Approach

Author
  • Li Ma (California Digital Library)

Abstract

E-resources are essential for academic library users, offering twenty-four seven access to extensive collections of journals, books, and databases alike from any internet-connected location. However, managing these resources presents increasingly complex challenges that demand coordinated expertise. This presentation explores how collaborative team approaches can effectively resolve e-resource access issues within medical library settings. Through eight detailed case studies, the author demonstrates that successful e-resource access management requires cross-functional collaboration among library staff, IT professionals, vendors, and security specialists. The author identifies three key success factors—Communication, Coordination, and Collaboration—and provides practical frameworks for building effective e-resource teams. This presentation emphasizes that while technical processes are important, human and organizational factors are equally critical for achieving sustainable e-resource success.

Keywords: e-resources, team collaboration, library systems, access management, medical libraries

How to Cite:

Ma, L., (2026) “Chart Your Course to E-Resource Success: A Team Approach”, NASIG Proceedings 40: 15. doi: https://doi.org/10.3998/nasig.11082

Published on
2026-10-08

License

CC-BY-NC 4.0

Introduction

E-resources are fundamental to academic libraries. In 2022, data from ARL indicated that libraries allocated an average of 75.4 percent of their materials budgets to subscriptions. While the exact electronic portion was not specified, this likely represents a significant share, aligning with historical trends in e-resource spending, as noted by Marshall Breeding.1 These resources offer undeniable benefits, such as twenty-four seven access, support for multiple simultaneous users, and powerful search capabilities. However, their management has become incredibly complex. The e-resource ecosystem is a web of intricate authentication systems, security protocols, and discovery systems. These technical components overlap with other aspects like content management, vendor relationships, and meeting end user expectations. This complexity creates challenges that no single person or department can tackle effectively on their own.

This presentation examines how team-based approaches to e- resource access management can transform reactive problem-solving into proactive, sustainable solutions, drawing from real-world experiences in a medical library setting.

Background

E-resources access management has evolved into a multisystem, multitechnology endeavor requiring diverse expertise. These challenges span three interconnected areas: technical infrastructure, content and metadata management, and user experience. Technical infrastructure involves managing various authentication methods including IP ranges, proxy servers, and other identity management systems such as Shibboleth and OpenAthens. Teams must also navigate network security platforms like Zscaler, accommodate device and browser variability, and ensure discovery system integration. Content and metadata management require handling entitlement complexities, adapting to journal and platform changes, addressing metadata quality issues, and maintaining knowledgebases. User experience demands managing expectations for seamless access while communicating effectively during service disruptions.

Successfully addressing these interconnected challenges requires collaborative expertise spanning acquisitions and licensing, library systems and IT management, metadata and cataloging, user experience design, campus IT security, and vendor relationship management.

Our Technology Environment

Understanding our library’s unique technology environment provides essential context for the following case studies. Duke University Medical Center implemented Zscaler cloud security several years ago as a comprehensive network protection solution.2 While this implementation preceded my arrival and was expertly managed by the original team, it established the foundation for our current collaborative troubleshooting approach.

As vendors update their platforms and security protocols, new Zscaler-related access issues continue to emerge. To address these evolving challenges, the Duke University Medical Center Library e-resource team collaborates with the Medical Center Library IT staff and Duke Health Technology Solutions (DHTS) staff to develop solutions for access problems that were not apparent during the initial implementation.

The following case studies demonstrate how we have extended this collaborative problem-solving framework, showcasing our team’s ability to identify emerging patterns in access disruptions and implement solutions for unprecedented technical challenges.

Methodology

This presentation examines eight distinct scenarios encountered in our medical library environment to illustrate how team-based approaches lead to successful e-resource access management and troubleshooting. Each case study follows a structured analysis framework that examines the initial problem, resolution approach, and collaborative elements that proved essential to success.

Case Studies Analysis

The following cases demonstrate how collaborative approaches transform complex technical challenges into manageable problems with sustainable solutions.

Case Study One: The Invisible Security Barrier

  • Scenario: Library staff could not access resources from office computers, while patrons reported no access issues—indicating a localized problem affecting only library workstations.

  • Resolution: Investigation revealed that newly installed Zscaler security protocols were blocking legitimate resource access from library computers. Collaboration with the DHTS team resulted in appropriate security setting adjustments that maintained protection while restoring access.

  • Collaborative Value: Success required coordination between librarians, IT staff, and vendors to resolve an issue invisible to individual troubleshooting efforts.

    Case Study Two: The Inconsistent Access Mystery
  • Scenario: On-campus users reported intermittent access failures to critical resources, creating service disruptions.

  • Resolution: Our e-resource team identified inconsistent behavior in the Zscaler application that affected how it recognized legitimate resources. DHTS specialists implemented targeted setting adjustments to ensure consistent recognition.

  • Collaborative Value: Diagnosis required specialized network and security software knowledge combined with cross-department coordination to identify and resolve system behavior that varied unpredictably.

    Case Study Three: The Domain Change Disruption
  • Scenario: Multiple patrons reported broken links within a major database, suggesting vendor infrastructure changes had occurred without notification.

  • Resolution: Our e-resource team obtained an updated domain list from the vendor and coordinated with IT to whitelist new domains, fully restoring access functionality.

  • Collaborative Value: This case highlighted the importance of maintaining communication channels between library and IT teams for rapid response to vendor infrastructure modifications that impact campus network security settings.

    Case Study Four: Vendor Response Time Challenges
  • Scenario: An important resource became suddenly inaccessible, with standard vendor customer service responding slowly to resolution requests during a critical access period.

  • Resolution: We leveraged established relationships to engage higher-level vendor contacts to reach technical decision-makers directly. This escalation enabled real-time collaboration with the vendor’s technical team through virtual meetings where both parties could troubleshoot configurations, test potential solutions, and identify the root cause together. This direct engagement significantly accelerated the resolution timeline compared to the standard ticket-based support process.

  • Collaborative Value: Success demonstrated the value of dedicated vendor relationship specialists and multilevel contact strategies for addressing critical access issues that exceed standard support response times.

    Case Study Five: Proxy Recognition Failure
  • Scenario: A vendor’s security system stopped recognizing the institutional proxy server, preventing authenticated access for all off-campus users.

  • Resolution: We collaborated with the vendor to establish a direct access link as an interim solution, ensuring uninterrupted access for users while the vendor investigated and resolved the underlying authentication issue.

  • Collaborative Value: Resolution required technical understanding of authentication systems combined with vendor negotiation skills to develop workaround solutions that provided access to library users.

    Case Study Six: ILL and E-Access Integration
  • Scenario: Article citations failed to populate properly in the ILL system, disrupting resource sharing workflows.

  • Resolution: Our metadata and ILL specialists collaborated to adjust the configuration of our library’s ILL system to populate the data elements (title, author, ISSN, etc.) passed via the citation database.

  • Collaborative Value: Success required specialized metadata expertise, ILL system knowledge, and link resolver understanding to restore integrated functionality across multiple platforms.

    Case Study Seven: Discovery System Inconsistencies
  • Scenario: Users could not access articles through the primary discovery tool, while access succeeded through an alternative discovery platform, creating confusion and service disruption.

  • Resolution: We worked with the third-party discovery vendor to determine that the issue stemmed from mislabeled article metadata on the vendor’s end, which interfered with their authentication system. The vendor corrected the metadata, restoring accurate discovery and access.

  • Collaborative Value: Librarian metadata expertise combined with vendor technical skills proved essential for identifying and resolving system integration issues affecting user experience.

    Case Study Eight: Hidden Article Discovery
  • Scenario: A patron could not locate a specific article through the library discovery tool despite confirmed institutional access to the resource.

  • Resolution: Investigation revealed that a journal name change had not been properly linked in the knowledgebase. Cataloging and e-resource management expertise was utilized to update metadata records and restore discoverability.

  • Collaborative Value: Resolution required expertise in cataloging and e- resource management to identify and resolve knowledgebase inconsistencies that affected resource discovery without obvious error messages.

The Three Cs Framework: Essential for E-Resource Success

Analysis of the eight case studies reveals three critical success factors for effective e-resource access management: Communication, Coordination, and Collaboration. These “Three Cs” are the bedrock upon which successful e-resource support is built.

Communication: Ensuring Clear Information Exchange

Strong e-resource teams excel at communicating with users in ways that resonate with them. This means translating complex technical problems into understandable, plain language, helping users grasp the nuances of their access issues, and demonstrating genuine empathy for their frustrations. Effective communication also involves rapid responses when problems emerge, diligent follow-ups to ensure full resolution, and consistent updates on progress throughout the entire process.

Coordination: Engaging the Right Expertise

Effective coordination establishes a clear support structure where everyone understands their role. This begins with frontline staff handling basic inquiries and common problems. As issues grow more complex, technical specialists with domain-specific knowledge are brought in. For the most challenging problems, experts from various departments are engaged, fostering a cross-functional approach. This structured method ensures that the appropriate individuals tackle each problem efficiently, minimizing wasted time and redundant efforts.

Collaboration: Fostering Cross-Departmental Teamwork

Great collaboration happens when teams share a commitment to solving problems quickly and effectively. It involves welcoming diverse ideas, regardless of departmental affiliation, and acknowledging each person’s contributions. Teams thrive through mutual learning and growth, building strong relationships by supporting one another through demanding troubleshooting sessions.

Building Effective Teams: Requirements and Implementation

While communication, coordination, and collaboration provide the foundational principles, the practical implementation of these ideas is crucial for successful e-resource teams.

Foundational Skills and Knowledge

Successful e-resource teams need a robust set of technical and process skills. Their core technical expertise should encompass several critical areas. This includes a deep understanding of authentication systems and security platforms, along with proficiency in discovery systems and link resolvers. Teams must also possess solid knowledge of metadata standards and understand the intricacies of e-resource lifecycle management and cross-system integration capabilities.

Beyond this essential technical knowledge, strong e-resource teams also require a keen set of process skills. This means being able to proactively monitor systems to prevent issues before they arise. They must also discern when and how to seek assistance effectively and maintain persistence when faced with difficult troubleshooting challenges. Given the rapidly evolving technological landscape, it is crucial for these teams to embrace continuous learning so they can adapt and grow.

Putting the Three Cs into Practice

The Three Cs framework translates directly into specific organizational practices. Teams should implement centralized issue tracking to identify patterns and facilitate knowledge sharing. Simultaneously, maintaining a tiered support structure ensures that each problem level is handled by the appropriate expertise. Success is further cultivated through mentoring relationships, celebrating cross-departmental contributions, and dedicating time for continuous learning and professional development.

Why These Principles Matter

These case studies consistently demonstrate that e-resource challenges transcend departmental boundaries. Technical issues intertwine with vendor relationships, security requirements, user experience, and content management needs. This inherent complexity demands collaborative approaches that integrate diverse expertise while keeping user needs at the center.

It is important to recognize that human and organizational factors matter just as much as technical knowledge. While technical skills are undeniably vital, it is ultimately the team’s culture, communication practices, and collaborative relationships that decide a library’s ability to navigate complex e-resources challenges and deliver consistent service.

Next Steps

Libraries should evaluate their existing support structures against the Three Cs framework, pinpointing areas where communication, coordination, or collaboration could be enhanced. Investing in team development, cross-training, and nurturing strong relationships with external partners—such as IT departments, vendors, and security teams—lays the groundwork for sustainable e-resource access management.

The tiered support approach is adaptable for libraries of all sizes, offering a structured framework for leveraging expertise while maintaining the flexibility to address unique challenges. Regularly reviewing common issues that arise also enables libraries to identify opportunities for systematic improvements and determine specific additional training needs for their teams.

Conclusion

The eight case studies in this presentation consistently show that e-resource access management demands collaborative expertise that goes beyond any single individual or department.

The Three Cs framework—Communication, Coordination, and Collaboration—offers practical guidance for transforming reactive troubleshooting into proactive, strategic management. This framework shows that technical proficiency alone does not guarantee success. Instead, organizational dynamics are key: a team culture that encourages cross-functional input, communication focused on user experience, and collaborative relationships that support quick responses to emerging issues.

The collaborative practices outlined here offer libraries a clear roadmap for maintaining seamless e-resource access in increasingly complex technological environments. Ultimately, long-term e-resource success relies on both mastering relevant technical knowledge and cultivating adaptable teams ready to evolve with technology and meet emerging user needs.

Contributor Notes

Li Ma is Assistant Director of Systemwide Licensing at the California Digital Library, Oakland, California, USA. At the time of the 2025 NASIG Conference, she was Associate Director for Content & Discovery at the Duke University Medical Center Library, Durham, North Carolina, USA.

Notes

  1. Marshall Breeding, “Academic Library Collections: Historic Trends and Future Outlook,” Computers in Libraries 44, no. 4 (May 2024): 17–19, https://www.proquest.com/trade-journals/academic-library-collections-historic-trends/docview/3046878186/se-2. ⮭
  2. Anu Moorthy and Barbara Dietsch, “Scaling the Library Resources with Zscaler,” NASIG Proceedings 37 (2023): https://doi.org/10.3998/nasig.4303. ⮭